So the lady who writes African Expat Wives club was fretting over negative comments left on her very insightful blog. I urge you to check out the story over there. One of the more telling posts includes the lines; “Living in East Africa today is not unlike a British 1950’s middle class existence for many expatriates”. and “Moving to Africa fast tracked my husband and I from renting a tiny flat in London to living comfortably in a three bedroom house with a four wheel drive, sizeable garden, a dog and reliable house help within one year” just to give you a taste.
Anyway, I posted a comment on her blog that I wanted to share. This is what I said:
The thing is, your blog reminds us Kenyans of how far we have to go before we eliminate the disparities in wealth and the racial segregation that those disparities manifest in Kenya.
Do I think you’re racist? No. But it shouldn’t matter. You should still keep blogging.
I do get put off by how unaware you seem of the ways that your lifestyle is a reflection of the problems that Kenyans have been trying to get over since the first White man landed on our soil (heck, we weren’t even Kenyan then, but how we all became Kenyans is a long story that I hope they taught in British schools).
I’m idealistic and I’d like to think that for all the lavish lifestyles that expats enjoy in Kenya they have a keen awareness of their privileged location in an exploitative international economic and political system. Your blog reminds us Kenyangs that you (expats) are all not driven by that awareness and few of you have a deep desire to subvert the system that has you at the top of the heap.
Question is; what should my reaction be? To post abusive comments on your blog? NO, thats just petty and mean.
My reaction needs to be to learn as much about, and understand your perspective so that when its time to turn the heap in favour of equitable distribution, I am able to treat you in a manner that respects your dignity.
Kenyans committed to change and social equity can either demonize expats for their lavishness, or be committed to every human being’s dignity; both the expat and her housegirl. That is a much more difficult and complicated task.
So blog on. No insults from me here. Dissapointment? Yes.
But if some day you decide to live for more than being at the top of the heap, meander on over to my blog or drop me an email and I can share some ideas for things you can do to help that will not overwhelm your delicate constitution. (this is in response to her understandable claim about down and dirty work in the slums that, “we are not all cut out for that kind of work”)
And I don’t say any of this meanly. Its just that I firmly believe that privilege brings with it responsibility to pay it forward and to undermine the very system that put you on top at the expense of others. I should know, I’m a Kenyan living most often in the U.S. but also in Kenya for parts of the year.
Be well and blog on!



12 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 26, 2008 at 4:06 pm
Seasons
I have actually read that blog and like the fact she gives us an insight to how ‘they’ view us.
I even commented that she should not fret coz we all get trolled once in a while. It actually happens to the best of us
March 26, 2008 at 4:42 pm
Irena
oh I cannot get the link..will try but oh my I have been venting about the expatriates for a long time now . Oh my can I read this blog, I’m sure a have a few things to say when I’m done reading the “insights of Expatriates in Africa” or maybe Gulag of African Expatriates..
March 26, 2008 at 6:06 pm
Mwananchi Mkenya
@Seasons: Welcome back! What, you think we didn’t notice the days you were gone?…. Will zoom on over to your place to see whats new in eager anticipation of a new post
@ Irena: oops. I corrected the link now. Have you got a blog? I’d love to read your vents!…..
March 27, 2008 at 6:52 am
Seasons
Oh my, I cant get away without y’all noticing huh? I actually traveled down south and came back with a massive cold or is it flu? Cant tell the difference.
Glad someone noticed though
March 27, 2008 at 2:21 pm
mrembo
I have started to comment about this particular post a number of times, stopped because I was thinking “what’s the point” then came back again after going back to the said blog.
I started off agreeing with your comment and ended up disagreeing with you.
March 29, 2008 at 1:44 pm
kye'
During the violence in Kenya after elections, there were very many kenyan bloggers who were on the ground giving us updates almost every hour but they were not praised in the US like they did to the Expat wife. I asked myself why? Was it racism? Did she come face to face with all the mayhem like mentalacrobats did in Kitale or Kenyanpudit, Karoki, the list is long. Do these expats mix the the locals and make friends and not blog about giving a watchman a used mattress and food. Disgusting I say.
March 29, 2008 at 5:14 pm
Mwananchi Mkenya
@ Mrembo: please please share how and why you disagree. I”m dying to hear…… please
March 30, 2008 at 5:49 am
midnight (.)(.)
Kye:
arent your expectations quite absurd? For example, if you were a mother of three kids and living in iraq where your hubby worked as a contractor. One day civil war broke out: decapitations, rapes, pillaging etc. what are you gonna do…. Go out to take pictures, ‘face to face’ with the mayhem in the middle of as fight you dont know much or care about… just so you can blog about it???
March 30, 2008 at 10:38 pm
kye'
@midnight
my expectations might be absurd to you and not to me, my tribe and a big number of Kenyans. I’m a parent with children so stop preaching to me about a mother with three children cos I have more, plus other children not mine but see to their everyday needs.
“if you were a mother of three kids and living in iraq where your hubby worked as a contractor. One day civil war broke out: decapitations, rapes, pillaging etc. what are you gonna do….” Cancel your contract and move to a place where you feel safe….easy
Credit goes to our people who gave us first hand updates cos they knew why there were fights and cared a lot and so did the rest of the country. If you don’t give a toss about a country you are living in why continue to live there?
March 31, 2008 at 7:27 am
midnight
Kye:
“Cancel your contract and move to a place where you feel safe….easy”
precisely, this is what expats are about, they are migratory cranes. They leave droppings behind – sometimes its a fertilizer, other times it just …droppings
What I did find odd about your comment more than the others was the element of expectation… on the one hand, an expectation of praise from the US for certain blogs (why should it matter ? and how do you know it wasnt there ?). I think you are seeing things in black-and-white, rather than technicolor.
And the other issue of expectation is that somehow higher standards were expected from this expat blogger (why ?). The fact that there was mayhem points to a lot of individuals, kenyans : who did not care / live up to expectations / were indifferent – while others who didnt neccessarily share the reasoning behind either sides position became easy targets, were evicted, sent away, etc..because they didnt meet certain expectations. Indifference is a general human trait, rather than a monopoly owned by a clique of people.
April 2, 2008 at 1:52 am
anon
Husijibu hii midnight pumbavu,
fala, mavi a kuku, nguruwe. Hawa mashonga wanacom huku kudoo? Waendelee kudrop juu kinywa ndio huletaa pumbavu kama wao balaa. Njivunia.Whoa there buddy!!
I completely respect your right to say whatever you want to say and to disagree with other posters. I however reserve the right to express my disagreement with your insults of others and to edit them out.
seriously, you can get the same message across without the insults if you just take out the words that I struck out.
April 2, 2008 at 11:12 am
mrembo
To quickly answer you, I felt that you were judging her for enjoying a life that most middle middle class and beyond Kenyans seem to enjoy.
Why the need for her to be responsible and give back to her community.
If you look at the average treatment of househelpers homestead employees in Kenya but thier fellow kenyan employers, most times it is appalling , so why jump on her for her lifestyle.
The whole whole response just felt judgmental and that she owes something because of her lifestyle.
I have just read Midnight’s response and I am with him on this one